Malingering and Deception Psychological Evaluationsin Chicago, Atlanta, and Fort Lauderdale

Insanity Defense

Malingering and Deception Psychological Evaluations

Psycholegal Assessments, Inc. specializes in conducting comprehensive malingering and deception psychological evaluations to assist courts, attorneys, and agencies in discerning the authenticity of reported psychological symptoms.  Psychological evaluations by forensic psychologist Dr. Steven Gaskell are grounded in empirical methods and tailored to address the complexities of each case.

Understanding Malingering and Deception

Malingering involves the intentional fabrication or exaggeration of psychological or physical symptoms for external gain, such as avoiding prosecution or obtaining financial compensation.  In forensic contexts, distinguishing genuine mental health conditions from feigned ones is crucial to ensure justice and appropriate treatment.


Malingering is not necessarily an either-or situation. The psychologist must be able to distinguish the actual psychological impairment or suffering from exaggerated or feigned symptoms. The detection of malingering requires clinical acumen, as well as sound psychological assessment and psychological testing. Psychologists need excellent clinical skills to detect the presence and extent of malingering during an evaluation and Dr. Gaskell has extensive experience in this area.

An Independent Medical Examination psychological evaluation is a one-time, non-treatment assessment conducted by a forensic psychologist. Unlike clinical consultations, Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs) are performed by professionals who have no prior relationship with the examinee, ensuring an unbiased and impartial evaluation. These assessments are crucial in determining the presence and extent of psychological conditions and their impact on an individual's functional abilities.

Our Evaluation Process

Our malingering and deception psychological evaluations involve:

Clinical Interviews

Interview to assess symptom presentation and consistency.

General Psychological Testing

Utilization of validated instruments, such as the MMPI-3, to detect atypical response patterns indicative of deception.

Specialized Testing for Exaggeration and Malingering of Symptoms

This could include such instruments as the SIRS-2; M-FAST; TOMM; MENT; SIMS

Collateral Information Review

Examination of medical, legal, and other records to corroborate reported symptoms

Behavioral Observations

Monitoring for inconsistencies between reported symptoms and observed behavior.

Dr. Gaskell's expertise ensures a meticulous approach to identifying potential exaggeration and malingering, providing courts with reliable and objective findings.

Applications of Our Evaluations

Our assessments are instrumental in various legal scenarios, including:

Competency to Stand Trial

Determining if a defendant is feigning symptoms to avoid trial or its consequences

Insanity Defense Claims

Assessing the legitimacy of mental illness claims at the time of the alleged offense.

Personal Injury Cases

Evaluating the authenticity of psychological damage claims.

Disability Determinations

Verifying the validity of reported impairments.

Serving Multiple Jurisdictions

We offer malingering and deception psychological evaluations in:

Chicago, Illinois

Chicago, Illinois

Atlanta, Georgia

Atlanta, Georgia

Fort Lauderdale, Florida

Fort Lauderdale, Florida

Evaluations can be conducted in-person or via secure telehealth platforms, ensuring accessibility and convenience.

Schedule a Free Consultation

For expert malingering and deception psychological evaluations, contact Psycholegal Assessments, Inc. at:

Visit contact page  to request an appointment

Areas of Expertise

Competency to Stand TrialCompetency to Stand Trial

Competency to Stand Trial, also known as Fitness to Stand Trial, is imperative for ensuring that a defendant can comprehend the nature and objective of the legal actions against them and actively cooperate with their defense attorney.

Psychosexual EvaluationsPsychosexual Evaluations

Psychosexual evaluations of sex offenders incorporate a comprehensive risk assessment utilizing actuarial instruments and other research-supported risk and protective factors.

Criminal ResponsibilityCriminal Responsibility

Criminal responsibility or sanity evaluations are critical when a defendant’s mental state at the time of committing an offense is in question. These evaluations can be initiated by the court, defense, or prosecution to establish a clear understanding of the defendant’s mental condition during the crime.

Independent Medical ExamIndependent Medical Exam

An Independent Medical Exam is conducted by a psychologist without prior involvement in the individual’s care, ensuring an objective assessment without a therapist-patient relationship.

Miranda Rights & Confession IssuesMiranda Rights & Confession Issues

The role of confessions and self-incriminating statements in criminal cases cannot be understated. Confessions are produced in about 50% of criminal cases, where suspects who provide self-incriminating statements are 26% more likely to be found guilty and convicted (Leo, 2006).

Malingering and DeceptionMalingering and Deception

In the legal realm, psychological assessments can be compromised by malingering or deception, with individuals potentially presenting themselves dishonestly during interviews and tests to influence the outcome.

Mitigating FactorsMitigating Factors

Mitigating factors consider the defendant’s mental state and historical mental disorders or psychological trauma, even when these do not qualify for an insanity defense, to argue for a reduced sentence. The contributions of evaluations and reports by experts like Dr. Steven Gaskell are vital for presenting such evidence.

Guilty But Mentally Ill (GBMI)Guilty But Mentally Ill (GBMI)

Introduced first in Michigan in 1975, the GBMI verdict was proposed to diminish the success rate of insanity defenses, offering a compromise verdict that, while seemingly compassionate, subjects the defendant to the same penalties as a guilty verdict.

Expert Forensic Psychologist Dr. Steven GaskellExpert Forensic Psychologist Dr. Steven Gaskell

Forensic Psychologist | Dr. Steven Gaskell

Dr. Steven Gaskell is a Forensic Psychologist who provides comprehensive, objective, thorough and credible forensic psychological evaluations for the court. The forensic psychological evaluations provide information relevant to the legal issue, while also considering the potential impact of the findings on the individual. Forensic Psychological Evaluations are completed for state and federal courts.

Contact US Today

Alternatively, contact us by email at drgaskell@gmail.com.

Licensed Psychologist in Multiple States

Practicing in Illinois, Georgia, Florida, Arizona, and Kansas.

Dr. Steven Gaskell

is a holder of the PSYPACT Authority to Practice Interjurisdictional Telepsychology (APIT)
 which allows him to provide competency to stand trial evaluations by telehealth across 42 States.  Furthermore, Dr. Gaskell possesses the Temporary Authorization to Practice (TAP) credential which allows him to provide temporary in-person competency to stand trial evaluation services in any of the 42 PSYPACT states.

Forensic Psychology Experience

Over 3,000 forensic psychological assessments conducted, including more than 850 competency evaluations.

Expert Witness Testimony

Dr. Gaskell has provided expert witness testimony in court on pretrial issues such as Competency to Stand Trial or Fitness to Stand Trial on numerous occasions.  

Video Conferencing Available!

Schedule your free video consultation today. HIPAA-compliant evaluations available across multiple states.

Video Conferencing Available!

Psychological evaluations are now able to be completed by HIPAA compliant video conferencing.

Request more details by filling out the form below.

Request Video Call

Video Conferencing Available!

Psychological evaluations are now able to be completed by HIPAA compliant video conferencing.

Request more details by filling out the form below.

Request Video Call
Expert Forensic Psychologist Dr. Steven Gaskell

Video Conferencing Available!

Psychological evaluations are now able to be completed by HIPAA compliant video conferencing.

Request more details by filling out the form below.

Request Video Call
Close